My battle, my recipes - Shared with you for inspiration & joy.

Banana Custard Banoffee Pie

Banana Custard Banoffee Pie

Though not actually a baking recipe there are elements in this that have been baked, although I didn’t bake the biscuits that went in the base of this. So, technically, there WAS baking. Just not by me. Alas. Still, it’s an invention, a creation. And it came from my messy mind. I’m proud of it, not least because I truly believe it’s a winner. Question. How do you take one of the world’s favourite desserts (banoffee pie) and make it better? Answer? Make banana custard and put it in between the caramel and cream layer of course!

I’d been toying with the idea for a while but just hadn’t got round to trying it out. Today, on a day when I was feeling brave enough to eat (though this wasn’t on the agenda) it just felt the time was right. The result was great, better than I even hoped. Watch the video, get the ingredients, make it and WOW your friends and family. Friends may never leave. Be warned.


For the base

300g milk chocolate digestives (crushed)

100g unsalted butter (melted)

For the caramel

100g soft dark brown sugar

100g unsalted butter

397g tin of sweetened condensed milk

For the banana custard

250ml full fat milk

1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract

2 egg yolks

45g caster sugar

1 teaspoon cornflour

25g plain flour

1 banana (mashed)

For the topping

1 banana (sliced)

300ml whipping cream (whipped)


Use a 23″ deep filled fluted loose bottom pie/flan tin or similar

Crush your biscuits (you can use ordinary digestives if you prefer) and add the melted butter to them. Combine thoroughly. Spread the mix all over the base of your tin and press down firmly and into the sides. Put it into the fridge to firm up whilst you prepare your caramel.

Put the butter and dark brown sugar into a saucepan and melt over a low heat. Only do this so that the sugar dissolves. Add in the condensed milk. Stirring constantly, let it come to a simmer and keep stirring for 6-8 minutes so that it thickens up and goes a rich, dark, golden colour. Remove from the heat and immediately pour into your biscuit base. Smooth it all over the base, trying to keep an even, level surface. Pop back into the fridge to cool.

Now onto the banana custard. Mash up your banana and put it to one side. Measure out 200ml of the milk and add the vanilla extract to it. Pop it into the microwave for 1 minute. This should get it hot but not boiling – that’s how you want it. In a bowl whisk the egg yolks and sugar together until they’re pale in colour and fluffy. Add the flour and cornflour to that and whisk again until you get a thick but smooth consistency. Add the remaining 50ml of cold milk and whisk that in. Now add this mixture to the warm milk and put it all in a saucepan, making sure it’s all whisked together first. Put on a low heat and stir constantly for 6-8 minutes until it thickens up. DO NOT LET IT BOIL. Remove from the heat, stir in your mashed banana.

Remove the tin with the biscuit base and caramel from the fridge and add the banana custard to the top, spreading over the caramel layer evenly (ensure, of course, that the caramel layer has cooled and set first). Pop in the fridge again to cool for about 30 mins to an hour.

Finally, slice up a banana. Randomly place over the top of the banana custard and then spread your whipped cream over the top of the lot. Decorate the top of the cream in whatever way you like. Some people dust with cocoa powder, some with crushed chocolate – I used a chocolate topping!

Enjoy your banana custard banoffee pie – and you WILL! 🙂

Feel free to share

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.